Chi Sim's Wooden Dommy or of Yip Man? Which one of them it arose first?

[O_COISA]

I have a doubt which Muk Yan Jong's (wooden dommy) form about would have arisen first, the one of system Chi Sin Weng Chun and of the system Yip Man Weng Chun?:confused:

The matter involves two systems. Am therefore placing this new topic to attract more people to the discussion.

Please, reply in YMWC, so that all discussion stays just in a Forum location.;)

Please, go until this link to reply:
:bazooka: http://hfy108.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=1184

[Andreas Hoffman]

In Weng Chun we have three fixed wooden dummy forms.

Heaven form
Man form
and Earth form

GM Yip Man´s versions are simillar to the Heaven form and some of his students are doing parts of Man and Earth form.